Research on donkey milk · Study 11

Do allergy antibodies recognise donkey milk?

In 2014 at the University of Camerino, Vincenzetti et al. examined whether antibodies from the blood of adults with cow's milk allergy bind in the laboratory to proteins from cow's, goat's and donkey milk.

Important: Blood samples from three adults were tested in the laboratory – not a drinking trial. Whether donkey milk is tolerated in cow's milk allergy cannot be derived from this. If an allergy is known, medical advice is advisable.
Publication
Vincenzetti et al.
2014 · Veterinaria Italiana
Study type
Preliminary
laboratory study
Blood samples
3 with (suspected) allergy
3 without allergy
Focus
Antibody binding to
milk proteins

What it's about

A question of proteins

In cow's milk allergy, the immune system forms IgE antibodies against certain milk proteins. Milk proteins from different animal species are partly similar – which is why many people affected also react to goat's or sheep's milk.

The protein composition of donkey milk differs considerably from that of cow's milk. The researchers wanted to know: do the antibodies of allergic people also recognise the proteins of donkey milk?

To find out, they separated the proteins of all three types of milk and tested them with blood serum from adults with and without cow's milk allergy.

What exactly was studied?

StudiedProteins from cow's, goat's and donkey milk
Tested withBlood serum from 3 adults with (suspected) cow's milk allergy
MeasuredBinding of IgE antibodies in an immunoblot
Not testedDrinking donkey milk, children, clinical reactions
ResultNo IgE binding to donkey milk proteins
LimitationVery small, preliminary laboratory study

Briefly explained

The terms used in this study

Immune systemIgE antibodies

Antibodies that play a central role in allergies. They recognise certain structures on proteins.

MethodImmunoblot

A laboratory test that shows which separated proteins antibodies from a blood sample bind to.

Milk proteinsCasein & whey

The two major protein groups in milk. Whey proteins include, for example, β-lactoglobulin and α-lactalbumin.

PhenomenonCross-reaction

Antibodies against one protein also recognise a similar protein from another source.

Step 01Separating

The proteins from cow's, goat's and donkey milk were separated into fractions by chromatography.

Step 02Characterising

Electrophoresis was used to determine which proteins the fractions contained.

Step 03Testing

The fractions were tested with serum from 3 people with (suspected) allergy and 3 control persons.

Step 04Comparing

For each person and type of milk, it was recorded which proteins antibodies bound to.

Interactive · The data at a glance

Where antibodies bind

For each blood sample: which proteins from cow's, goat's and donkey milk did the antibodies bind to? And how do the types of milk differ in their protein?

weakclearstrongn. d. = not determinable or not contained

Schematic illustration of the immunoblot results described in the article (selection of protein fractions). The strength of binding is shown qualitatively.

Key findings

What the researchers report

Cow's milk

Binding in all three samples

3 of 3with (suspected) allergy
0 of 3controls
mainly to caseins

The antibodies mainly recognised casein fractions of cow's milk, in one case also β-lactoglobulin.

Goat's milk

Partial cross-reaction

2 of 3with (suspected) allergy
0 of 3controls
weaker than with cow's milk

Two sera also bound to caseins of goat's milk – an indication of similar protein structures.

Donkey milk

No binding found

0 of 3with (suspected) allergy
0 of 3controls
for the fractions studied

The antibodies did not bind to the protein fractions of donkey milk studied in any sample.

One of the three persons (3A) only had a suspected cow's milk allergy. Individual casein fractions of donkey milk could not be separated with the method used. The authors themselves describe the study as preliminary and consider further studies necessary.

Critical assessment

A laboratory finding, not a tolerability test

What the study shows

✓
Three types of milk were tested side by side with the same blood samples.
✓
The antibodies recognised cow's milk proteins and partly goat's milk proteins.
✓
They did not bind to the donkey milk proteins studied in any sample.
✓
In the samples, donkey milk contained around half as much casein as cow's milk.

What it does not show

×
No statement on whether people with cow's milk allergy tolerate donkey milk.
×
Only three blood samples from adults – no children, no drinking trial.
×
Not all protein fractions of donkey milk could be tested.
×
It remains unclear whether the amount of casein or the protein structure is decisive.

Research question for DON DONKEY’S®

What does the protein profile of our donkey milk look like?

The study shows how much depends on the individual proteins. For us, this is a reason to know the protein composition of our own milk more precisely – and to follow research on this topic.

01 · PROTEIN PROFILEHave the protein fractions of our own batches analysed independently.
02 · RATIOCompare the casein and whey proportions across seasons.
03 · EXCHANGEGet in touch with the research group in Camerino.
04 · RESEARCHFollow and support larger, independent studies.

Original publication

Hypoallergenic properties of donkey’s milk: a preliminary study

Vincenzetti S., Foghini L., Pucciarelli S., Polzonetti V., Cammertoni N., Beghelli D., Polidori P.
Veterinaria Italiana · 2014 · 50(2):99–107
University of Camerino, Italy

DOI: 10.12834/VetIt.219.125.5
Full text: PDF of the original publication

The publication describes a preliminary laboratory study. The term "hypoallergenic" in the title is a scientific classification by the authors and not a product-related statement for DON DONKEY’S®.

DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk

From our shop

DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk

100 % donkey milk · raw milk, frozen

On this page we report the findings of a published study. Independently of that, you will find our donkey milk here: 100 % donkey milk, frozen as raw milk.

Transparency: The study examined antibody binding to milk proteins in the laboratory, not the tolerability of DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk. Our donkey milk is a food.
€24,90

100 ml bottle / 100ml · Unit price: €249,00 / 1 l · incl. VAT, plus shipping

View all sizes & purchase options →
Donkey Milk Powder

Also in our shop

Donkey Milk Powder

Donkey milk in powder form

For anyone who prefers a longer shelf life: our donkey milk in powder form – easy to store and portion.

Transparency: The study examined antibody binding to milk proteins in the laboratory, not the tolerability of our donkey milk powder. Our donkey milk powder is a food.
€24,90

20g · Unit price: €1.245,00 / 1 kg · incl. VAT, plus shipping

View all sizes & purchase options →