Research on donkey milk · Study 50

What lives in raw donkey milk? An inventory

A team from the Cyprus University of Technology monitored the raw milk of a donkey farm microbiologically over eight months and identified the bacteria of eleven jennies by genetic analysis. The result is a profile of the bacteria in the milk of this farm.

Important: A microbiological examination of a single farm. It describes which bacteria were found – it shows no effect of donkey milk and cannot be transferred to other farms.
Publication
Papademas et al.
2020 · J. Dairy Sci.
Study type
Laboratory study
culture & 16S sequencing
Samples
33 weekly samples
+ 11 individual jennies
Location
Donkey farm, Larnaca
Cyprus

What it's about

Two views of the same milk

Classic milk checks grow bacteria on culture media and count the colonies. But this only finds what grows well in the laboratory. Genetic sequencing, on the other hand, reads a piece of bacterial DNA from the sample and thus also shows bacteria that cannot be cultured.

The Cypriot team combined both: regular culture checks over eight months and sequencing of the milk of individual jennies. Fat, protein and dry matter were also determined.

What exactly was studied?

Culture33 weekly samples, Oct. 2018 – May 2019
SequencingMilk from 11 jennies, May 2019
Herd20–25 milked jennies, without antibiotics
Method16S rDNA, region V3–V4
Milkavg. 0.84 g fat · 1.62 g protein / 100 mL
Limitationone farm, short period

Briefly explained

Tools of microbiology

Method16S rDNA

A gene section that all bacteria carry. Its variations reveal which genus it is.

CountTotal bacterial count

All bacteria that grow on a standard culture medium – given as log CFU per millilitre.

GroupProteobacteria

A large phylum of mostly gram-negative bacteria that includes many environmental bacteria.

IndexShannon index

A measure of diversity: the higher it is, the more different bacteria in balanced proportions.

Step 01Collect

One sample per week from the herd's daily milk, for eight months.

Step 02Culturing

Total bacterial count and a targeted search for E. coli, Listeria, Bacillus cereus and others.

Step 03Sequencing

Milk from 11 jennies: bacterial DNA read and assigned to genera.

Step 04Comparing

Proportions of genera, diversity and differences between the jennies.

Interactive · The data at a glance

A profile of the milk bacteria

How the samples were collected, what the bacterial count showed, which genera dominated, how few lactic acid bacteria were among them – and how diverse the samples were. Switch between the views.

Culture checks33weekly samples from October 2018 to May 2019, each from the daily milk of 20–25 jennies
Sequencing11individual jennies in May 2019, two samples each, Illumina sequencing of the 16S rDNA
One farm in Larnaca · healthy jennies without antibiotic treatment

Values from the freely available version of the study (arXiv preprint). The journal version appeared in the Journal of Dairy Science.

Key findings

What the researchers report

Culture checks

Low bacterial counts on this farm

avg. 3.80 log CFU/mL

Over eight months, bacterial counts remained low. E. coli, Listeria monocytogenes and Bacillus cereus were not detected in any of the 33 samples.

Sequencing

Environmental bacteria shape the picture

Sphingomonas up to 47 %

Proteobacteria such as Sphingomonas, Mesorhizobium and Pseudomonas accounted for the largest share. In two jennies, Acinetobacter was conspicuously frequent.

Lactic acid bacteria

Only a small proportion

1–4 % · Ø 2,42 %

Lactobacillus and Streptococcus were present, but rare. The authors see this as confirming that donkey milk contains mainly gram-negative bacteria.

According to the authors, it remains open where the bacteria come from – the environment, skin, udder or the animal itself. They recommend further studies with more samples.

Critical assessment

A profile, not a seal of quality

What the study shows

✓
The raw milk of this farm had low bacterial counts during the study period.
✓
Sequencing found mainly gram-negative environmental bacteria and only a few lactic acid bacteria.
✓
There were differences in the bacterial pattern between individual jennies.

What it does not show

×
No statement about other farms – microbial profiles depend strongly on husbandry and hygiene.
×
No effect of donkey milk or its bacteria on humans.
×
No testing for salmonella, yeasts or moulds – these were not reported.

Research question for DON DONKEY’S®

What is the microbial profile of our raw milk?

This study shows how the bacterial pattern of donkey milk can be recorded precisely. For us, it is a model of transparency: regular laboratory testing documents the microbiological quality of raw milk.

01 · TESTINGDocument regular laboratory testing.
02 · LITERATURECompare with other microbiological studies (cf. studies 4, 5 and 46).
03 · PROCESSESReview milking and chilling processes on the basis of the findings.
04 · EXCHANGEGet in touch with dairy hygiene laboratories.

Original publication

Investigation of donkey milk bacterial diversity by 16S rDNA high-throughput sequencing on a Cyprus donkey farm

Papademas P., Kamilari E., Aspri M., Anagnostopoulos D. A., Mousikos P., Kamilaris A., Tsaltas D.
Journal of Dairy Science · online 2020 · volume 104, pp. 167–178

DOI: 10.3168/jds.2020-19242

A microbiological examination of a farm in Cyprus – no product-related statement for DON DONKEY’S®.

End of the study summary
Note on our products

The study summarised above was carried out independently of DON DONKEY’S® and does not relate to our products. It serves solely to inform about the state of research.

DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk and donkey milk powder are foods. They are not intended to prevent, treat or cure any disease and do not replace medical advice.

DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk

From our shop

DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk

100 % donkey milk · raw milk, frozen

On this page we report the findings of a published study. Independently of that, you will find our donkey milk here: 100 % donkey milk, frozen as raw milk.

Transparency: The study examined raw milk from a farm in Cyprus – not DON DONKEY’S® donkey milk. Microbiological findings only ever apply to the farm and period studied.
€24,90

100 ml bottle / 100ml · Unit price: €249,00 / 1 l · incl. VAT, plus shipping

View all sizes & purchase options →
Donkey Milk Powder

Also in our shop

Donkey Milk Powder

Donkey milk in powder form

For anyone who prefers a longer shelf life: our donkey milk in powder form – easy to store and portion.

Transparency: The study examined fresh raw milk, not our donkey milk powder.
€24,90

20g · Unit price: €1.245,00 / 1 kg · incl. VAT, plus shipping

View all sizes & purchase options →